Apple Becomes a Safe Haven Amid AI Turmoil: Up About 30% This Year, 37x P/E Ratio Hits Nearly 20-Year High

Deep News11:51

As AI-related stocks continue to face pressure, Apple (AAPL.O) has become a safe-haven choice for some Wall Street investors. However, as the stock price keeps climbing, the tech giant's valuation has reached its highest level in nearly 20 years, raising questions about its upside potential.

So far this year, Apple shares have gained about 30%, making them the best performer among the "Magnificent Seven." Apple currently has a market capitalization of $5.1 trillion, and its stock gains have contributed about 28% of the S&P 500's 7.2% rise this year. Apple's forward price-to-earnings ratio for the next 12 months has reached 37 times, the highest since 2007, placing it among the 25 most expensive companies in the S&P 500.

Rising AI investment risks make Apple a safe haven for capital

Recently, U.S. tech stocks have continued to come under pressure. As the market reassesses returns on artificial intelligence infrastructure investment and the capital expenditure pressure on large tech companies, chipmakers, cloud computing firms, and computing power service providers have generally faced sell-offs.

Apple, however, has shown strong resilience. Compared with tech giants that are investing heavily in AI data centers, Apple has maintained a relatively restrained capital expenditure strategy, relying mainly on the iPhone, Mac, and its consumer electronics ecosystem to generate revenue and cash flow.

Bernstein analyst Mark Newman noted in a November 12 report that Apple can avoid the risks posed to semiconductors, memory chips, and other upstream suppliers by a decline in AI data center capital expenditures, and is also less affected by shrinking free cash flow at large cloud computing companies. Newman believes that given Apple's customer loyalty, earnings sustainability, growth capability, free cash flow generation, and shareholder returns, its higher valuation is somewhat justified.

Market volatility data also reflects investors' expectations for Apple's stability. The Cboe Apple Volatility Index, which measures expected volatility in Apple's stock price, has fallen nearly 10% this month, while the volatility gauge for the Nasdaq 100 has risen 25% over the same period.

Product sales have also provided support. Apple's first foldable phone launched this year, the iPhone Duo, has a starting price of nearly $2,000 but still triggered consumer buying frenzies, with demand for high-end devices serving as an important support for its fundamentals.

37x P/E ratio reveals a gap between valuation and earnings growth

Apple's continued stock rally has also widened the gap between its valuation and future earnings growth. Bloomberg data shows that Apple's current price/earnings-to-growth ratio has reached 5.3, the highest since comparable data began in 2005. By contrast, Nvidia's PEG is below 0.15, mainly because the market expects its profit to double this fiscal year, while previous stock adjustments have already significantly lowered its valuation.

Apple's own revenue growth is facing pressure to slow. The market expects the company's revenue growth to fall from 15% in fiscal 2026 to 10% in fiscal 2027 ending September 2027, and then slow further over the following two fiscal years.

Rising costs may also affect profitability. Although Apple's latest earnings report in early November beat Wall Street expectations, its margin outlook was disappointing. The company's latest quarterly gross margin was 47.9%, and it is expected to fall to 45% to 46% in the current quarter, with higher memory chip prices and supply constraints posing the main pressure.

YieldMax ETFs strategist Mike Khouw believes that Apple is currently in a favorable market environment, but from a historical valuation perspective, there is already limited room for further P/E expansion. The strategist estimates that if the market compresses Apple's valuation premium relative to the S&P 500 from about 100% to 50%, its forward P/E ratio could fall below 28 times, corresponding to a downside risk of nearly 27% from the current stock price. However, this is only a valuation scenario estimate.

Wall Street divisions widen, average target price below stock price

Apple's ever-rising stock price has begun to challenge analysts' valuation judgments. Of the 59 Apple analysts tracked by Bloomberg, only 36 give a buy rating. Apple's current stock price has already exceeded the average analyst target price, making it the only company among the "Magnificent Seven" with a negative implied return over the next 12 months.

Still, some investors remain optimistic about Apple's unique position in the AI investment cycle. Dan Niles, founder and portfolio manager of Niles Investment Management, listed Apple as one of his top five stocks this year. Niles believes that if the AI industry continues to expand, consumers will still need to use related services through smartphones and computers, and Apple is expected to benefit from its huge base of end users; if the AI investment cycle weakens, its lower dependence on data center construction and computing power investment may continue to play a defensive role. He pointed out that Apple's significant outperformance of other large tech stocks this year has already demonstrated the advantages of this business structure, but its current excessive valuation remains its biggest flaw.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment