Nvidia investors face uncertainty around CEO succession, the AI ecosystem, export controls and China
Nvidia shares rose 3% early Wednesday.
In terms of its numbers, Nvidia took a confident tone with Wall Street on Tuesday. But analysts say a lack of answers to some bigger questions could keep the stock in check for the foreseeable future.
Nvidia's (NVDA) earnings call offered "as much as could be expected under the circumstances" to address concerns associated with the CEO transition, TD Cowen analyst Joshua Buchalter wrote in a note. The topic of future leadership is a source of "immense" uncertainty following the resignation of Jensen Huang a week ago.
Analysts harbor concerns over what the company will look like without Huang. Bernstein analyst Stacy Rasgon said he and his team "remain more in the camp that Jensen's removal is going to be problematic, and unfortunately not nearly enough time has passed yet to confirm or disprove those fears."
A second lingering issue for investors is the durability of Nvidia's supplier relationships in the artificial-intelligence ecosystem.
Nvidia's growth trajectory remains closely tied to spending from leading AI labs, which remains "largely outside" the company's control, said Jefferies analyst Blayne Curtis. While he believes Nvidia's "demand is hard to argue with," he wrote in a Tuesday note that investors will be looking for strength in the AI ecosystem that would be needed to quell uncertainty over the company's outlook moving forward.
The company acts as a chip supplier for OpenAI and Anthropic as well as an investor with massive equity stakes in both companies.
The matter of China-linked sales leads to two more unresolved questions for Nvidia investors, according to analysts.
One is the issue of whether Nvidia products are making it into China via intermediaries and in violation of export rules on advanced chips. Nvidia "did nothing to assuage growing concerns about its sales to Asian data centers providing service to [Chinese] AI labs," Seaport Research analyst Jay Goldberg wrote in a note.
He added that Nvidia "stated that they did not forecast any Hopper revenue from [China], which is overly specific and avoids the larger question." Hopper is an older line of Nvidia chips.
A related uncertainty concerns newly implemented rules from the U.S. Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security, which put the company's business under "additional scrutiny," Buchalter at TD Cowen wrote.
On Monday, the BIS issued an interim final rule to prevent Chinese companies from tapping into AI chips through "remote access," a practice by which countries like China can make use of U.S. advanced chips via data centers in third countries, often in Southeast Asia.
Buchalter noted that Nvidia's management indicated confidence that the company can reallocate supply to other customers unaffected by the rule.
But Wolfe Research's Chris Caso noted that he has "decided not to follow management" in raising the forecast for next year, given that it's too soon "to fully ascertain the impact of both the export controls, as well as uncertainty regarding the departure of a high-profile CEO."
As for what the uncertainty means for the stock, J.P. Morgan analyst Harlan Sur warned in a Wednesday note that it will likely remain volatile in the near term.
-Nora Redmond -Hannah Pedone
Comments