Bonds Rallied 6.1%. Gold Fell 6.3%. I Had Blamed Yields

Mathematical Money | November 17, 2026


Between 5 and 30 October, the fund that holds long US government bonds rose 6.1%. The biggest gold fund fell 6.3%.


On 6 October I wrote that gold was falling because long-term yields were so high. I also wrote down a test. If yields came down and gold didn't rally, then gold "has a problem that has nothing to do with rates".


Yields came down. Gold didn't rally. So my own test says I was wrong, or at least only partly right.


Gold fell again last week. It closed Monday at its lowest in 13 months, 28.7% below its January peak. So what's actually pushing it?


What happened last week?


Gold fell 6.8% in five sessions. In the same five sessions the long-bond fund fell 3.0% and the dollar fund rose 2.0%.


Bonds down, dollar up, gold down. That fits the old story nicely, which is exactly why I don't trust it. A single week fits almost any story.


Did my yield story fail?


In October, yes. Between 5 and 30 October, bonds rose 6.1%, which means long yields fell. The dollar didn't move at all, 0.0%. Gold fell 6.3%.


Neither of the usual suspects was pushing. Yields were helping gold, the dollar was neutral, and gold still fell.


Then gold bounced back to where it started by 9 November, and then fell 6.8% in a week. Over the whole stretch from 5 October to Monday, bonds are 3.1% higher and gold is 6.8% lower.


Why does a bond fund tell you about yields?


Bond prices and yields move in opposite directions. When long yields fall, the price of a long bond rises, and a fund that holds only long bonds rises with it. So TLT going up 6.1% in October is the same fact as long yields coming down.


That's why it's a clean test of my 6 October idea. Gold pays nothing, so it should love falling yields. The fund price is the cheapest way to check without arguing about which yield, which day or which source.


The fund is a stand-in, not the yield itself. It holds bonds of 20 years and longer, which is the part of the curve my post was about. Its 5 October close was the lowest in my 19 months of data. That's the same Monday my 6 October post said the 10-year hit its highest yield since 2002.


Is it the dollar?


More than it is bonds, but not as much as the headlines suggest.


The dollar fund is up 11.1% since gold's peak on 29 January, and it closed Monday at its highest in 19 months. Its low was two days before gold's high.


Day by day since the peak, gold moves against the dollar more than twice as closely as it moves with bonds. That's real. But the two together explain only about a quarter of gold's daily moves. The other three quarters is something neither one shows.


What would each answer look like?


There are three readings, and each one predicts something different on the days when gold falls.


If it's rates, gold falls when bond funds fall. October said no.


If it's the dollar, gold falls when the dollar fund rises. Last week said yes. October said no again, because the dollar fund finished the month exactly where it began.


If it's neither, gold falls on days when both sit still. That describes most of October. It's the answer I like least, because it isn't something you can look up.


How do you check a "this is why it moved" story yourself?


You only need free closing prices for the asset and for the thing people blame.


1. Write the test down before the move, with a date. "If yields fall and gold doesn't rally, I'm wrong" is a test. "Gold is weak because of rates" is a mood.

2. Pull the closes from the day you wrote it, for the asset and the driver.

3. Look at the whole stretch, not the last week. Last week fit rates and the dollar perfectly. October fit neither.

4. Ask how much of the move the story leaves unexplained. Here it's about three quarters.


If the story only works in the window where you went looking, it's a coincidence with a headline.


Is gold cheap now?


I don't know, and I don't hold any. A 13-month low and a 28.7% drop say what happened. They say nothing about next month.


What I'd watch is the quiet days. When the dollar and bonds sit still and gold still falls, like most of October, something else is selling it, and nobody outside can see who.


I picked the bond market's side in October and the bond market did its part. Gold ignored it for a month and then punished it for a week. If you trade or hold gold, what are you actually watching? The two things I gave you in October just failed their own test.


Sources: closing prices from Tiger Brokers for GLD (gold fund), TLT (long US government bond fund) and UUP (dollar fund), 5 October to 16 November 2026. The 6 October post is "Everyone's Talking Debasement. Gold Peaked In January And Is Down 26%." The "quarter" is the share of gold's daily moves explained by the dollar and bond funds together, a simple regression on 201 daily returns since 30 January. It is a rough guide, not a model. Fund prices are proxies for gold, long bond yields and the dollar, not the things themselves.


$GLD$ $TLT$

#gold #macro #treasuries #dollar #investing


Stop guessing. Start calculating.


Live to fight another day. 🤙

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment

  • Top
  • Latest
empty
No comments yet