CPF vs CICT: Which Made More Money Over 18 Years? The Numbers May Surprise You.


🚨 If you bought 1,000 shares of CapitaLand Mall Trust (now $CapLand IntCom T(C38U.SI)$  ) in 2008 and forgot about it... here is exactly how much money you’d have today. 🚨


Most people think investing requires constantly injecting fresh cash. But what happens if you let a high-quality Singapore REIT fund its own growth using nothing but its dividends?


Here is the ultimate "Lazy Investor" math experiment from 2008 to 2026.


📈 The Strategy:


• Start with 1,000 units in 2008.


• Never invest another cent of your own money.


• Take up every single rights issue by borrowing, then let future dividends automatically pay off that debt.


⏱️ The Timeline of Free Growth:


The Start (2008):


Share Count = 1,000 units.


The 2009 GFC Lifeline:


CMT announced a massive 9-for-10 rights issue at S$0.82. You score 900 new units for a total cost of S$738. Instead of paying out of pocket, you add this to your "dividend tab."


👉 New Share Count = 1,900 units.


The Debt Clear Era (2009–2012):


Pulling in a conservative long-term average of S$0.10 per unit annually, your 1,900 units make S$190/year. By the end of 2012, your dividends completely wiped out your S$738 debt.


The 2024 Expansion:


Fast forward through the 2020 merger into CICT. In Sept 2024, they run a preferential offering (56-for-1000 at S$2.007). You pick up another 106 units, creating a minor debt of S$212.74, which your dividends quickly swallow up again.


🚀 The Final Exit: Selling Out on 3 Jul at S$2.40 🚀


If you decided to cash out your entire portfolio on 3 Jul at the market price of S$2.40 per share, here is what your final payday looks like:


💰 The Final Cash-Out Math:


• Initial Investment (2008): S$2,810 (1,000 units @ ~S$2.81)


• Final Share Balance (2026): 2,006 units (Doubled for FREE)


• Selling Price (3 Jul): S$2.40 per unit


📊 The Ultimate ROI Scorecard:


• Initial Capital Outlay: S$2,810.00


• Final Stock Liquidation Value: S$4,814.40 (2,006 units × S$2.40) • Net Cash Dividends Kept: *S$3,000.00* (Pure profit left over)


• Total Wealth Generated: S$7,814.40


• Total Net Profit: 🟢 S$5,004.40


🏆 Total Absolute Return: +178.1%


You nearly tripled your money on a defensive brick-and-mortar retail asset by doing absolutely nothing for 18 years.


💡 The Mic-Drop Realization:


Notice something insane? Your dividends alone (S$3,000) completely paid back your entire initial investment (S$2,810) and then some—leaving you with a pure cash surplus. Meanwhile, your share capital quietly doubled itself in the background.


That is what real, stress-free compounding looks like in the Singapore market. 🇸🇬✨






To see if the REIT strategy actually beat the ultimate risk-free benchmark in Singapore, let's look at the numbers if you put that exact same cash timeline into your CPF Special Account (SA) earning a guaranteed 4% p.a.


Here is what happens if you mirror the exact same injections (Initial Capital + 2009 Rights + 2024 Rights) into CPF SA from 2008 to July 2026.


🏦 The CPF SA 4% Timeline

Jan 2008 (Initial Deposit): S$2,810.00


Feb 2009 (Top-up matching 2009 Rights): +S$738.00


Sep 2024 (Top-up matching 2024 Rights): +S$212.74


Total Out-of-Pocket Cash Injected: S$3,760.74


🔍 Key Takeaways from the Matchup

1. The Out-of-Pocket Difference


With the REIT strategy, the S$950.74 needed for rights issues was *entirely funded by the asset itself* via dividends. For the CPF SA strategy, you had to manually inject that extra S$950.74 out of your own pocket to match the timing, bringing your total capital used to S$3,760.74.


2. Wealth Generation


Despite the market price of CICT dropping from S$2.81 (2008) to S$2.40 (2026), the sheer volume of dividends and the 100% expansion in share count allowed the REIT strategy to generate S$1,257.74 more in net profit than the CPF SA.


💡 The Verdict

While CPF SA gave a beautiful, stress-free +99.6% return (almost doubling your money with zero market volatility), the CICT REIT strategy won out by leveraging its own internal cash flow to fund growth, yielding a massive +178.1% on your actual out-of-pocket cash.


# 💰Stocks to watch today?(15 May)

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment3

  • Top
  • Latest
  • InverseCramer
    ·07-06 17:54
    TOP
    Amazing calculation! I don’t have any REITs 😢😢😢
    Reply
    Report
    Fold Replies
    • InverseCramerReplying toShernice軒嬣 2000
      Got it boss 🫡
      07-06 19:57
      Reply
      Report
    • Shernice軒嬣 2000
      Don't waste money on REITs. The dividends you collect may eventually be offset by rights issues that require you to put your money back in.
      07-06 19:56
      Reply
      Report